Phytochemical Screening and In vitro Study of Free Radical Scavenging Activity of Flavonoids of Aloe vera
Kumar A.1*, Mahajan A.2, Begum Z.3
1Department of Biotechnology, I. K. Gujral Punjab Technical University, Jalandhar, Kapurthala. India
2,3Department of Biotechnology, Saheed Udham Singh College of Engineering and Technology, Mohali (PB), India
*Corresponding Author E-mail: ashoka.kumar2007@rediff.com
ABSTRACT:
Aloe is a very popular plant, and present study aimed to correlate the flavonoids and their antimicrobial activity, antioxidant activity and nitric oxide scavenging activity. So, phenolic content and flavonoids were determined and studied in vitro their antimicrobial activity, antioxidant activity and nitric oxide scavenging activity with well diffusion method, minimum inhibitory concentration and scavenging by 2, 2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) radical and nitric oxide radicals (NO.) respectively with reference of Ascorbic acid as standard. The phenolic content was analysed by Folin Ciocalteu's phenol reagent and flavonoids with aluminium chloride. Phenolic content and flavonoids contents were 16.971mg tannic acid equivalent/g and flavonoids was 21.84mg Querecetin/g of extract powder respectively of Aloe leaves. The MIC value of extracts ranges between 0.95µg – 1.24µg against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. The flavonoids inhibited significantly DPPH radical with IC50 value of 893µg as compared to standard IC50 - 714µg. IC50 of nitric oxide is 973µg as compared to standard IC50 -500µg. These results represent the contents of phenolic components and flavonoids in Aloe and their correlation with antimicrobial activity, antioxidant activity and nitric oxide scavenging activity.
KEYWORDS: Aloe vera, Antimicrobial, Antioxidant, Flavonoids, Nitric oxide scavenging,
INTRODUCTION:
Free radicals play an important role in biological process such as host defence, over-production of hydroxyl radical (.OH), hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), superoxide anions (O2--) and nitric oxide (NO) which contributes in cancer, AIDS, diabetes, hypertension etc. [1,2]. However, Antioxidant reduced oxidation of other molecules as lipids, proteins by inhibition of oxidative chain reaction [3]. When lipids oxidized with free radical reaction then it lead for degradation of foods and that can minimize by antioxidant [4]. Plant’s phytochemicals viewed a good alternative natural antioxidant and found to be useful for free radical pathology and food industry.
Oxidation of food is influence for destruction of food, loss of nutritional value and rate of oxidation can be reduced by antioxidants. Now, phytochemicals are going to improve quality of food with slow oxidative degradation of lipids [5,6].
Aloe is widely distributed plant and traditionally used as cosmetics and pharmaceutical purpose in all over. It’s used for treatment of wounds, burns and constipation from thousands of years [7]. It has pharmacological properties such as hypoglycaemic effect on diabetic mellitus, antibacterial, antifungal, anticancerous, anti-inflammatory, immune-stimulant, and antioxidant [8]. Aloe juice has bitter taste and contains aloin, anthreaquinone, isobarbaloin, emodin, ester of cinnamic acid that play an important role in treatment of cancer, ulcer, and diabetes. Presence of phytochemicals such as alkaloid, carbohydrate, tannin, steroid, tri-terpenoids, glucose, and galactose was confirmed in extracts of Aloe by HPTLC method [9]. There are many ingredients isolated and studied for their biological activities. Pharmacological ingredients as anthreaquinone, aloe-emodin, and barbaloin prominent free radical scavenging activity. Phenolic compound such as alkaloids and flavonoids are natural occurring phytochemical and expressed antimicrobial, anti-mutagenic, anti-inflammatory and hepatoprotective [10,11].
The present investigation is employed for extraction of leaves and isolation of phenolic compound as flavonoids from Aloe vera and study their phytochemical screening, antimicrobial, antioxidant and Nitrous oxide scavenging activity.
MATERIAL AND METHOD:
Crude Drug Extraction:
Aloe vera’s leaves were collected near to Chandigarh, India and identified by Gaurav Srivastav (Botanist) and dried at room temperature in absence of light after washed. Obtained powder (100gm) after milling was subjected to extraction with methanol & water in ratio of 60:40 at Soxhlet for 48hrs. The obtained extract was concentrated in oven at 600C and store at 40C for further used.
Phytochemical Screening:
A minimum amount of extracts were used for phytochemical screening for compound as total phenol, alkaloids, flavonoids, tannins, Saponins, steroids, terpenoids, carbohydrate and glycosides. According to selected method with little modification, 2.0gm of plant extract was dissolved in 10ml double distilled water and filtered with filter and further used for phytochemical screening [12].
|
Component Exit Test |
Protocol for Test |
Result for Confirmation |
|
Alkaloids |
1.0ml extract + 3.0 drops of Dragendoff’s reagent |
Orange-red precipitate |
|
Flavonoids |
1.0ml extract + few drops of dil. NaOH |
Intense yellow colour |
|
Total phenol |
1.0ml extract + 2.0ml water + few drops of 10% FeCl3 |
Blue-green colour |
|
Tannins |
100mg solvent free extract + 1ml 5% FeCl3 |
Bluish- black precipitate |
|
Saponins |
1.0ml extract + 20ml water + agitation for 15min. |
1cm layer of foam |
|
Steroids |
1.0ml extract + 10ml CHCl3 + 10ml conc. H2SO4 |
Upper layer – red and lower layer – yellow-green |
|
Terpenoids |
5.0ml extract + 2.0ml CHCl3 + 3.0ml conc. H2SO4 |
Reddish brown precipitate |
|
Carbohydrate |
2.0ml extract + 2 drops of Molish reagent (95% α-Napthol in ethanol) + 2.0ml conc. H2SO4 |
Purple colour at junction |
|
Glycosides |
5.0ml extract + 2.0ml CHCl3 + 2.0ml CH3COOH |
Violet, blue to green colour |
Determination of Total Phenolic Component:
Total amount of phenolic contents was determined using method by Folin Ciocalteu's phenol reagent with slight modification. 1.0ml of sample was mixed with 2.0ml of Folin Ciocalteu's phenol reagent (10%). After 3 min, 1.0 ml of saturated Na2CO3 (~35 %) was added to mixture and made up to 10 ml by adding distilled water. The reaction was kept in the dark for 90 min, observed under UV-Vis spectrophotometer at 760nm absorbance. Tannic acid was used as a standard with varied concentration from 50 ppm to 200 ppm. A calibration curve was constructed with different concentrations of Tannic acid (0.01- 0.1mM) as standard. The results were expressed as mg of Tannic acid equivalents/g of extract and same procedure was done with extract and calculated as mean value ± SD (n = 3) [13].
Determination of Flavonoid Content:
Flavonoids content of isolated crude extract was determined by method with slight modification. Take 0.5ml of the sample (Extract) containing 1.25ml of distilled water. Then added 0.075ml of 5 % sodium nitrite solution and allowed to stand for 5 min. Added 0.15ml of 10 % aluminium chloride, after 6 min 0.5ml of 1.0M sodium hydroxide were added and the mixture were diluted with another 0.275ml of distilled water. The absorbance of the mixture at 510nm was measured immediately. The flavonoid content was expressed as mg of Quercetin equivalents/g sample and same procedure were done with Extract of all plants and calculated as mean value ± SD (n=3) [13].
Column Chromatography and Thin Layer Chromatography:
Combined solvent (Toluene: Ethyl acetate: formic acid in ratio of 7:5:1) was used as mobile phase in silica gel column chromatography (200g, 60-200 mesh). 10gm extracts was loaded in glass column with silica gel and 150ml of solvent system (Toluene: Ethyl acetate: formic acid) was used for running sample. For confirmation of separation, thin layer chromatography was performed by taking sample with mobile phase. The analysis of flavonoids was performed on silica gel coated TLC plates using 10µl of sample. The mobile phase for TLC was Toluene: Ethyl acetate: formic acid (7:5:1) and fractions were further screened for flavonoids [14,15].
Spectrophotometer and HPLC:
For determination of flavonoids content, spectrophotometric wavelength was considered on UV/Visible spectrophotometer (Shimadzu) with spectra (200-500nm) using Querecetin dehydrate as standard. 1ml of fraction, 1ml of pure water, 5ml acetate buffer (pH-3.8±0.5), and 3.0ml AlCl3(0.1M) solution added and after shaking kept for 30minuts. Absorbance was measured in 200-400nm of sample [16]. After consideration of wavelength, reversed-phase high performance chromatography was performed for determination of flavonoids in extracts. The 20µl of column chromatography purified liquid extracts was injected into HPLC (reversed phase, C18, 250mm x 416mm, Shimadzu) at 350nm for 16min at 1.0ml/min with HPLC grade Methanol : Water (60:40) mobile phase [17,18].
Antibacterial Activity:
Four pathogenic bacteria namely Escherichia coli (MTCC 25922), Bacillus subtilis (MTCC 3256), Pseudomonas aeuroginosa (MTCC 1688) and Staphylococcus auerus (MTCC 6810) were collected from MTCC, Chandigarh. For preparation of inoculums, they were sub-cultured in test tube containing 10ml nutrient broth and standardized with saline water. Agar well diffusion was used with slight manipulation. 0.5ml (9.0 x 104 CFU/ml) of 48 hrs old cultures of test organisms was inoculated into different sterile petri-plates and 15-20ml sterile media was poured into each petri-plate (90 x 90mm). The petri-plates were gently shaken for proper mixing and allowed to solidify. Thereafter, four wells were punched of 5mm diameter with a sterilized cork borer. For each well 50μl (25 - 100µg/ml) of flavonoids were added. The plates were incubated at 370C for 24 hrs and then zone of inhibition in mm was measured. The experiment was carried out in triplicates and calculated as mean value ± SD (n = 3) [12].
Antioxidant Activity:
The antioxidant activity of the flavonoids and the standard was assessed on the basis of the radical scavenging effect of the stable 1, 1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH-0.002% in methanol) method. The diluted working solution of the flavonoids (10 mg/ml) was prepared using the respective solvents. 10mg/ml of Ascorbic acid used as reference for compare results of plant extracts. In 3ml of total reaction solution, 2ml of flavonoids/standard solution (200-1000µg/ml) and 1.0ml of DPPH were mixed and allowed to react at 370C for 30 min. afterward, absorbance value were measured at 520nm and converted into percent antioxidant activity. The percentage antioxidant activity was calculated by following formula and calculated as mean value ± SD (n = 3) [19].
Percent (%) inhibition of DPPH activity = (A – B)/A *100
Where
A = Absorbance of the blank and B = Absorbance of the sample
Nitric Oxide Radical Scavenging Activity:
Scavengers of nitric oxide complete with oxygen, leading to reduced production of nitrite ions. Aloe flavonoid was dissolved in distilled water for this quantification. 2ml Sodium Nitroprusside (5mM) in standard phosphate buffer saline (0.025mM, pH-7.4) was incubated with 0.5ml of different concentration (200-1000μg/ml) of flavonoids were incubated at 29oC for 3 hours. Control experiment without the test compounds but with equivalent amount of buffer was conducted in an identical manner. After 3 hours incubated, samples were diluted with 1 ml of Griess reagents (prepared by mixing equal volume of 1% sulphanilamide in 2% phosphoric acid and 0.1% Naphthylethylene diamine dihydrochloride in water) and incubated for 30min. The absorbance of the colour developed during diazotization of Nitrite with sulphanilamide and its subsequent coupling with Napthylethylene diamine hydro-chloride was observed at 550nm on spectrophotometer. Same procedure was done with ascorbic acid, which was standard in comparison to extract. Calculated the % inhibition by formula and plot graph in compared to standard and calculated as mean value ± SD (n = 3) [20,21].
![]()
Where,
Acontrol = Absorbance of control reaction
Atest= Absorbance in the presence of the samples of extract.
Statistical Analysis:
The date recorded during investigation, were analysed with applying of Student t-test at excel sheet and signified the data at p<0.05% for organisms and solvents.
RESULT AND DISCUSSION:
Herbal medicines contain many constituents and can be separated by chromatographic techniques. There are many references [14-18] present to characterize the different components and their activity. Present studies reported that Phenolic compounds are well known antioxidant and scavenging agents and flavonoids is one of them. Flavonoids are secondary metabolites of plants and expressed as antimicrobial, antioxidant, scavenging activity, carcinogenesis and other diseases.
Phytochemical Screening:
Qualitative phytochemical screening carried on Aloe vera extracts showed the presence of phenolic compounds, flavonoids, alkaloids, amino acids, carbohydrates, reducing sugar, glycosides, tannins, and saponins. The results revealed the presence of medicinal as well as physiological active compounds [22].
Table-1: Phytochemical screening of Aloe vera leaves
|
Parameter |
Alkaloids |
Glycosides |
Reducing sugar |
Phenolic compound |
Steroids |
Terpenoids |
|
Aloe vera |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
|
Parameter |
Carbohydrates |
Protein |
Amino acids |
Flavonoids |
Tannins |
Saponins |
|
Aloe vera |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
Phenolic compounds are major constituents, present as secondary metabolites in Aloe and other plants. Quantitative analysis of total phenolic content in leaves extract was 16.971mg Tannic acid equivalent/g and flavonoids was 21.84mg Querecetin/g of extract powder respectively with reference of standard curve (tannic acid-y=0.015x + 1.004, R2 =0.994 and Querecetin= y=0.001x + 0.019, R2 = 0.998). These phytochemicals are responsible for antimicrobial and antioxidant activity of this plant’s flavonoids [23].
Table – 2: Quantity of total phenolic content and flavonoids
|
S. No. |
Parameter |
Quantity |
Standard |
|
1 |
Total Phenolic content |
16.971 (32%) |
Tannic acid |
|
2 |
Flavonoids |
21.84 (24%) |
Querecetin |
The combined solvent system was used for column chromatography and TLC and total five fractions were collected as per their polarity nature and screened for flavonoids and further mixed the entire fraction and dry that with evaporation of solvent. The weight and yield percentage of flavonoids fraction in Aloe vera extracts is 0.41gm/100gm and had percentage of 0.41%. After that spectral analysis of flavonoids showed multiple peaks in selected range of 200 to 500nm. After consideration of UV-spectrum for flavonoids at 221nm, 298nm, 375nm, 420nm, 430nm, and many more but after selection showed 350 nm and 430nm. High liquid chromatography was performed at 375nm [24-26].
Fig. 1: Graphical representation of flavonoids of Aloe vera by HPLC
Antibacterial Activity:
A significant antibacterial activity of flavonoids of Aloe has showed against selected pathogens. In dose dependent with flavonoids, zone of inhibition is ranged from 9.3 to 15.3mm being more for S. aureus at 100µg and minimum for E. coli at 25µg. With respect to individual pathogens, S. aureus showed maximum inhibition at 100µg whereas E. coli inhibition showed less at 75µg. In Recently, it has been reported antimicrobial activity of Aloe’s ethanolic extracts. But with aqueous extract, no activity is reported and Minimum Inhibitory concentration (MIC) value of flavonoids against selected pathogens as E. coli, B. subtilis, S. aureus and P. aroginosa is 76.06µg. recently reported that ethanol and methanol extract showed more antimicrobial activity [27].
Fig. 2: Graphical representation of Antimicrobial activity of flavonoids of Aloe vera
Free Radical Scavenging Activity:
Antioxidant are used as food preservatives for stabilize food composition and safety from free oxygen and other significant species from loss the quality. In present, free radical scavenging activity of flavonoids of Aloe were studied by DPPH scavenging assay. In this assay, a stable free radical, neutralized with antioxidants. The DPPH contain odd electron, which is responsible for absorbance at 520nm with visible purple colour. In vitro, the antioxidant activity of flavonoids of Aloe vera showed significant comparison with ascorbic acid as standard [28]. The IC50 of standard and flavonoids was 500.03µg with reference of standard curve (Y=0.036X and R2= -5.45) and 972.51µg with reference of standard curve (Y=0.088X + 96.68 and R2=0.988) respectively. The percentage inhibition of scavenging activity of flavonoids and ascorbic acid were reveal in graph. The scavenging activity of flavonoids was maximum 82.45 at 200µg/ml whereas lowest 8.84 at 1000µg ml. Flavonoids expressed antioxidant activity in dose-dependent manner similar in standard. This test showed release of electron or hydrogen to neutralize the free electron in solution. The result suggested that flavonoids are more able for scavenging of free radicals [12,28].
Fig. 3: Graphical representation of DPPH scavenging activity of flavonoids of Aloe vera
Nitric Oxide Scavenging Activity:
The procedure is based on the principle that, sodium nitroprusside in aqueous solution at physiological pH, spontaneously generates nitric oxide which interacts with oxygen to produce nitrite ions that can be estimated using Griess reagent. Nitric oxide is a strong intermediate of physiological process of human being such as platelets aggregation inhibition, muscle liberalization, neuronal signaling and cells mediated toxicity. Its diffusible free radicals, that play an effective role in biological system included messenger, antimicrobial and anti-cancerous activity. Nitric oxide form cytotoxic molecules peroxy-nitrite by reaction with superoxide anion. Flavonoids are significantly inhibited nitric oxide in dose dependent manner of 200 - 1000µg/ml. The IC50 of standard and flavonoids was 714.28µg with reference of standard curve (Y=0.070X and R2= -42.6) and 892.85µg with reference of standard curve (Y=0.056X and R2= -5.80) respectively. The percentage inhibition of scavenging activity of flavonoids and ascorbic acid were significantly (p < 0.05) reveal in graph. Toxicity of nitric oxide increased when it react with superoxide and form peroxynitrite anion and become a strong oxidant and that can decompose with antioxidant. The result showed that flavonoids might be capable of inhibiting nitric oxide and suggest for use as drugs in indigenous diseases [29].
Fig.4: Graphical representation of Nitric oxide scavenging activity of flavonoids of Aloe vera
CONCLUSION:
In summary, the obtained results showed that Aloe’s flavonoids showing antimicrobial activity and free radical scavenging activity against DPPH and nitric oxide radicals. The present study showed that flavonoids posses’ antimicrobial activity against pathogenic bacteria Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis, Pseudomonas aeuroginosa and Staphylococcus auerus and this study suggested that flavonoids would be a potential natural antimicrobial and antioxidant, have expectant value for prevention or slow the growth of pathogen and procession of reactive free radicals and related oxidative stress. Further chemical analysis, column chromatography and HPLC carried for confirmation of flavonoids and this avenue open new drug development.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
We are thankful to Centre for Microbiology and Biotechnology, Bhopal and SUS college of engineering and Technology, Tangori, Mohali, for supporting this research work. We are also very thankful to Dr. M. Murlidhar (Assistant Professor, Department Of Zoology, Regional Institute of EducationBhopal) for prepare this manuscript.
REFERENCE:
1. Darley-Usmar V, Wiseman H, Halliwell B, Nitric oxide and oxygen radicals: a question of balance. FEBS Lett., 1995, 309: 131–135.
2. Harman D. Aging: phenomena and theories. Ann NY Acad Sci, 1998, 854:1-7.
3. Velioglu YS, Mazza G, Gao L, Oomah BD, Antioxidant activity and total phenolics in selected fruits, vegetables, and grain products. J. Agric. Food Chem., ,1998, 46: 4113–4117.
4. Aruoma OI, Free Radicals in Tropical Diseases. Harwood Academic Publishers, UK. 1993,111-136.
5. Nogochi C, Nikki E, Phenolic antioxidants: a rationale for design and evaluation of novel antioxidant drugs for atherosclerosis. Free Rad. Biol. Med., 2000, 28: 1538–1546.
6. Wang J, Yuan X, Jin Z, Tian Y, Song H, Free radical and reactive oxygen species scavenging activities of peanut skins extract. Food Chem., 2007, 104: 242–250.
7. Davis, H.R. Aloe vera: A scientific approach. Published by Vantage Press, New York. 1997, 3-5.
8. Saritha V, Anilakumar KR, Khanum F: Antioxidant and antibacterial activity of Aloe vera gel extracts.” International. Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biotech. Arch. 2010, 1: 376-384.
9. Nishant Kumar Ojha, Anil Kumar. HPTLC profile of aqueous extract of different chromatographic fractions of Aloe barbadensis Miller. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Disease, 2012, S104-S108.
10. Eshun K and He Q. ―Aloe vera: A Valuable Ingredient for the Food, Pharmaceutical and Cosmetic Industries—A Review,‖ Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 2004, 44(2): 91-96.
11. Talmadge, J.; Chavez, J.; Jacobs, L.; Munger, C.; Chinnah, T.; Chow, J.T.; Williamson, D.; Yates,K. Fractionation of Aloe vera L. inner gel, purification and molecular profiling of activity. Int. Immunopharmacol. , 2004, 4:1757-1773.
12. Kumar, A., Sharma, P., Mahajan, A., and Begum, Z. In Vitro Comparative Study of Antioxidant and Antibacterial Activity of Selected Dietary Plants. Nepal Journal of Biotechnology, 2019, 6(1):39-45.
13. Spanos GA, Wrolstad RE: Influence of processing and storage on the phenolic Composition of Thompson seedless grape juice. JAgric Food Chem. 1990, 38:1565-1571.
14. Cai W., Gu X., Tang J. Extraction, purification, and characterisation of the flavonoids from Opuntia milpa alta skin”. Czech J. Food Sci., 2010, 28: 108–116.
15. Yahaya Mobmi Musa. Isolation and Purification of Flavonoids from the leaves of locally Produced Carica papaya. International Journal Of Scientific and Technology Research, 2015, 4:282-284.
16. Guang Li, Shuang Yu, Yong-Hong Zhou and Qing-Fu Chen Spectrophotometric Determination of Flavonoids Content in Leaves of Fagopyrum cymosum Complex. Asian Journal of Chemistry, 2013, 25 (13):7575-7578.
17. Silva L, Pezzini BR, Soares L. Spectrophotometric determination of the total flavonoid content in Ocimum basilicum L. (Lamiaceae) leaves. Phcog Mag, 2015, 11:96-101.
18. Karagianis G, Viljoen A, Waterman PG. Identification of major metabolites in Aloe littoralis by high-performance liquid chromatography-nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Phytochem Anal. 2003, 14(5): 275-80.
19. Kikuzaki H, Nakatani N: Antioxidant effect of some ginger constituents. J Food Sc. 1993, 58:1407-1410.
20. Garrat DC: The quantitative analysis of drugs. 3rd edition. Japan. Chapman and Hall. 1964.
21. Sreejayan, N., and Rao, M. N. A. Nitric oxide scavenging by curcuminoids. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology. 1997, 49:105–107.
22. Sofowra, A. Medicinal Plants And traditional Medicine in Africa. Ibadan, Nigeria. Spectrum Books Ltd. 1993.
23. Singleton, V. L., Rossi, J. A. Colorimetry of total phenolics with phosphomolybdic-phosphotungstic acid reagents. American Journal of Enology and Viticulture, 1965, 16:144-158.
24. Ravi, S., Kabilar, P., Velmurugan, S. Ashok Kumar R., Gayathiri, M. Spectroscopy studies on the status of aloin in Aloe vera and commercial samples. Journal of Experimental Sciences. 2011, 2:10-13.
25. Nowak, R., Cybul, M., Starek, K. Chromatographic evaluation of phenolic acids in some cultivated Aloe species. Annales Universitatis Maria Curie-Sklodowska. 2009, 22:113-120.
26. Patel, D. K., Patel, K., Dhanabal, S. P. Phytochemical standardization of Aloe vera extract by HPTLC techniques. Journal of Acute Disease. 2012, 1:47-50.
27. Alemdar, S., Agaoglu, S. Investigation of in vitro antimicrobial activity of Aloe vera juice. Journal of animal and veterinary advances. 2009, 8:99-102.
28. Ozsoy, N., Candoken, E., Akev, N. Implications for degenerative disorders: Antioxidative activity, total phenols, flavonoids, ascorbic acid, β-carotene and β-tocopherol in Aloe vera. Oxidative medicine and cellular longevity. 2009, 2: 99-106.
29. Kammoun, M., Miladi, S., Ali, Y. B., Damak, M., Gargouri, Y., Bezzine, S. In vitro study of the PLA2 inhibition and antioxidant activities of Aloe vera leaf skin extracts. Lipids in health and disease. 2011, 11: 10- 30.
Received on 08.04.2019 Modified on 30.06.2019
Accepted on 28.08.2019 © RJPT All right reserved
Research J. Pharm. and Tech 2020; 13(2):593-598.
DOI: 10.5958/0974-360X.2020.00112.2